When an injured worker has impairments to more than one body part, the default rating method in California compresses them. The Combined Values Chart in the AMA Guides, which the Permanent Disability Rating Schedule incorporates, combines ratings so that two 20 percent impairments produce something less than 40 percent. The math reflects the assumption that each additional impairment applies to a smaller remaining whole person. For many injured workers, that assumption badly understates how their conditions interact in daily life. The Kite line of cases gives applicants' attorneys a way to challenge it.
The default rule
Under the 2005 PDRS, multiple impairments are combined using the Combined Values Chart after adjustment for diminished future earning capacity, occupation, and age. The formula is designed to keep the whole person rating at or below 100 percent and to avoid double counting. It works reasonably well when impairments are truly independent, such as a finger amputation and a hearing loss.
It works poorly when impairments compound each other. A worker with bilateral knee injuries cannot compensate with the other leg. A worker with a lumbar spine impairment and a hip impairment on the same side faces gait and transfer limitations that neither condition alone would produce. The CVC treats those conditions as though they barely overlap, and the rating suffers accordingly.
Kite
In Athens Administrators v. Workers' Compensation Appeals Board, commonly called Kite, a 2013 decision in which the Court of Appeal denied the employer's writ petition, the Appeals Board affirmed a rating that added rather than combined the applicant's bilateral hip impairments. The agreed medical evaluator explained that, in his opinion, adding the impairments more accurately reflected the applicant's level of disability because of the synergistic effect of the two injuries on the applicant's ability to function. The Board accepted that reasoning, emphasizing that the AMA Guides themselves describe the CVC as a method that may be departed from when a physician explains why another method produces a more accurate rating.
Kite did not overrule the CVC. It recognized that the CVC is rebuttable, and that a physician's well-reasoned explanation can support an alternative method, including straight addition.
What the physician must say
Kite claims are won or lost on the medical-legal report. Judges and the Appeals Board have repeatedly rejected additive ratings where the physician simply stated that the impairments should be added, without explanation. A report that supports a Kite rating generally needs to:
- Identify the specific impairments and their individual ratings under the Guides.
- Explain how the impairments interact functionally, with reference to the applicant's actual limitations.
- Describe why the CVC result understates the applicant's overall impairment in this case.
- State that, within reasonable medical probability, adding the impairments, or using another identified method, more accurately reflects the applicant's impairment.
- Ground the opinion in examination findings and the applicant's reported functional loss, not in general statements about the CVC's shortcomings.
The strongest reports tie the synergy explanation to activities of daily living. A physician who explains that the applicant's right shoulder impairment prevents use of a cane that would otherwise compensate for the left knee impairment has described real interaction. A physician who says only that the conditions are both painful has not.
Which cases fit
Kite arguments are most persuasive in a few recurring patterns:
- Bilateral injuries to paired extremities, where the uninjured side normally compensates.
- Adjacent or kinetically linked body parts, such as the lumbar spine and hip, or the cervical spine and shoulder.
- Upper and lower extremity combinations that together eliminate compensation strategies.
- Physical and psychiatric overlap, where chronic pain and a psychiatric condition reinforce each other, though psychiatric add-ons face separate statutory limits.
Impairments that are truly independent, such as a hand injury and a hearing loss, are poor Kite candidates. Pressing an additive argument on unrelated conditions undermines credibility for the claims where it genuinely applies.
Working with the evaluator
Most panel QMEs and AMEs do not address Kite unless asked. The applicant's attorney should raise the issue directly, either in the initial cover letter or in a supplemental request, by asking the evaluator to address whether combining the impairments under the CVC accurately reflects the applicant's overall impairment, and if not, which method does and why.
Frame the question neutrally. Evaluators react poorly to letters that argue for a result. A question that asks the physician to consider the functional interaction and explain their opinion, whichever way it comes out, produces a more credible report. If the evaluator declines, a deposition can explore the functional interaction in detail, which sometimes leads the physician to reconsider.
Defense responses
Defendants typically challenge Kite ratings on three grounds: the explanation is conclusory, the physician did not consider the CVC as the starting point, or the additive method double counts limitations already captured in each individual rating. The best defense to those challenges is a report that explicitly starts with the CVC, explains why that result is inaccurate in this applicant's circumstances, and addresses double counting by describing limitations that arise only from the combination.
Additional coverage of rating disputes, including apportionment and the medical-legal process, appears in our workers' comp section. For applicants with parallel civil claims, the rating also affects damages modeling discussed in case law and settlements.
The value at stake
The difference between combined and added ratings can be substantial. Two impairments that combine to a modest whole person rating may produce a meaningfully higher figure when added, and because permanent disability indemnity increases nonlinearly as ratings rise, the dollar difference grows faster than the percentage difference. Once total ratings reach the higher bands, life pension eligibility and settlement leverage change significantly.
The bottom line
The Combined Values Chart is a default, not a mandate. Where an applicant's impairments genuinely compound each other, Kite allows the evaluator to say so and rate accordingly. The work is in the report: specific functional interaction, explicit consideration of the CVC, and a clear explanation of why another method is more accurate. Ask the question early, ask it neutrally, and build the record that lets the rating reflect how the injured worker actually lives.










