Workers' Comp

The Six-Month Rule for Psychiatric Claims: Working the Sudden and Extraordinary Exception

California bars most psychiatric injury claims from workers employed less than six months.

Warehouse aisle with tall storage racks and a hard hat on the floor

California bars most psychiatric injury claims from workers employed less than six months. The sudden and extraordinary exception is the main way through, and the record has to be built for it from the first interview.

New hires are injured at disproportionate rates. They are less familiar with equipment, less likely to know where the hazards are, and more likely to be assigned the work senior employees avoid. When one of those workers suffers a psychiatric injury, California's workers' compensation system presents a threshold problem that has nothing to do with medicine: Labor Code section 3208.3(d) bars compensation for psychiatric injury unless the employee has worked for the employer for at least six months. For applicants' attorneys, the statute's single exception, a psychiatric injury caused by a sudden and extraordinary employment condition, is where most of these cases are won or lost.

What the statute says and does not say

Section 3208.3(d) is short. It requires six months of employment with that employer, it provides that the six months need not be continuous, and it states that the limitation does not apply when the psychiatric injury is caused by a sudden and extraordinary employment condition. Several practical consequences follow.

  • Prior stints with the same employer count toward the six months, even if separated by a gap. Seasonal and rehired workers often clear the threshold once all periods are added up, so pull the full employment history before conceding the bar.
  • The rule is employer-specific. Time with a predecessor entity, a staffing agency, or a related company may or may not count depending on who is the employer for comp purposes. In dual-employer arrangements, that question deserves its own analysis.
  • The statute limits compensation for the psychiatric component. It does not bar the physical injury claim, medical treatment for the physical injury, or temporary disability tied to physical restrictions.

The six-month question is also separate from the predominant cause threshold in section 3208.3(b). An applicant who clears the six-month rule still must prove that actual events of employment were the predominant cause of the psychiatric injury, and an applicant who invokes the sudden and extraordinary exception still must prove causation.

The sudden and extraordinary exception

The exception has two elements, and both are contested. The event must be sudden, meaning it occurred without warning rather than developing over time. It must also be extraordinary, meaning it is the kind of occurrence that would naturally be expected to cause psychic disturbance even in a diligent and honest employee, and something other than a regular and routine employment event.

The leading appellate authority is Matea v. Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (2006) 144 Cal.App.4th 1435, in which a retail employee was injured when lumber fell from a rack onto his leg. The court rejected the argument that the event had to be catastrophic or unheard of, and held that a falling-lumber accident could qualify as sudden and extraordinary because it was not the kind of thing an employee in that job would expect to happen. Since Matea, the Appeals Board has applied the exception to events such as robberies, assaults, explosions, and unexpected industrial accidents, while declining to apply it to injuries arising from common workplace hazards in a given industry.

That last point is where defendants focus. If falls from ladders are routine in roofing, a defense attorney will argue that a roofer's ladder fall is regular and routine even if it is sudden. The applicant's answer has to be factual and industry-specific: what made this particular event out of the ordinary for this job, this worksite, and this employee.

Building the record for the exception

Because the exception turns on how the event happened, the evidence that wins it is usually gathered early and has little to do with the psychiatric reports.

  • The applicant's account. Take a detailed narrative at intake about what happened, what warning existed, and what the applicant had seen or been trained to expect. Vague descriptions at the first interview are hard to fix later.
  • Co-worker testimony. Witnesses who have done the same job for years can testify that they had never seen this kind of incident. That testimony speaks directly to the extraordinary element.
  • Employer records. Incident logs, OSHA 300 logs, and safety committee minutes show how often similar events occurred. A clean history supports the exception; a pattern of similar incidents cuts against it.
  • Police and emergency reports. For violent incidents, outside reports establish suddenness and severity without relying on the applicant's later recollection.

The medical-legal reporting matters too. The psychiatric or psychological evaluator should address the mechanism of injury in concrete terms and explain why this event, as opposed to the general stress of a new job, produced the psychiatric condition. A report that lists generalized workplace stressors alongside the incident invites the argument that the psychiatric injury was caused by routine employment conditions rather than the sudden event.

When the exception will not hold

Some cases will not support the exception: cumulative stress claims, harassment claims that developed over weeks, and injuries from hazards common to the trade. In those files, the analysis shifts to what remains. The physical claim and its treatment continue, and so does any civil exposure. Harassment and discrimination that produced the psychiatric harm may support a FEHA claim outside the comp system, and a third-party tortfeasor may be liable for the full range of damages, including emotional distress. Our workers' comp archive covers the third-party track, and our practice operations coverage addresses intake screening for cross-referral to civil counsel.

The six-month rule rewards careful fact development and punishes assumptions. Count every period of employment, interview witnesses on how unusual the event was, and make sure the medical-legal record ties the psychiatric condition to the specific incident rather than to the job in general.

Who LawyersTrend is for

Three ways in

Selling to the PI bar? See sponsor and advertiser options.