A hiker falls through a rotted footbridge on a private ranch. A child is injured on a backyard trampoline at a neighbor's home. A cyclist strikes a cable strung across a private access road. Each of these premises cases may run into Civil Code section 846, California's recreational use statute, which provides that an owner of an interest in real property owes no duty of care to keep the premises safe for entry or use by others for any recreational purpose, and no duty to warn of hazardous conditions. When the statute applies, it defeats an ordinary negligence claim. The cases that survive do so through one of three statutory exceptions.
The scope of the immunity
Section 846 was enacted to encourage landowners to open their property to the public for recreation without fear of liability. Courts have read it broadly. The statute lists a wide range of recreational purposes, including hiking, riding, swimming, camping, sightseeing, and viewing or enjoying natural or scenic sites, and the list is illustrative rather than exhaustive. In Ornelas v. Randolph (1993) 4 Cal.4th 1095, the California Supreme Court held that the immunity applies regardless of whether the property is suitable for recreational use, rejecting the argument that a property strewn with farm equipment was outside the statute because it was not the type of land people normally use for recreation.
The immunity belongs to owners of any interest in real property, which can include lessees, easement holders, and other occupants. It does not depend on whether the land is rural or residential. It also applies to private landowners only; public entities rely on separate immunities in the Government Claims Act, which have their own terms and exceptions.
The threshold question is whether the plaintiff was on the property for a recreational purpose. That is often contested. A guest visiting a friend's house for dinner who trips on a step is not engaged in recreation in the statutory sense, while a guest invited to swim in the pool may be. The plaintiff's purpose, the defendant's purpose in allowing entry, and the nature of the activity all bear on the analysis.
Exception one: willful or malicious failure to guard or warn
The statute does not limit liability for willful or malicious failure to guard or warn against a dangerous condition, use, structure, or activity. Willful misconduct requires more than negligence or even gross negligence. Courts generally look for three elements: actual or constructive knowledge of the peril, actual or constructive knowledge that injury is a probable rather than a possible result, and a conscious failure to act to avoid the peril.
The evidence that establishes willful misconduct usually comes from the defendant's own history with the hazard. Prior injuries at the same location, complaints from neighbors or visitors, internal discussions about repairs that were never made, and the defendant's own testimony about what he knew are all central. A cable across a road that the owner installed knowing that cyclists and motorcyclists used the road, without flagging or signage, presents a stronger willful misconduct claim than a natural condition the owner never noticed.
Exception two: consideration
The immunity does not apply when permission to enter for recreation was granted for consideration. Paid entry fees, membership dues, and rental payments can all qualify. The question is whether the payment was made in exchange for the right to enter or use the property for recreation. Courts have examined arrangements such as campground fees, paid hunting access, and event admission. Payments that are incidental or unrelated to the recreational entry may not count, so the precise financial relationship between the plaintiff, or the group the plaintiff came with, and the landowner should be documented early.
Exception three: express invitation
The immunity also does not apply to persons who are expressly invited rather than merely permitted to come onto the premises by the landowner. This exception is where many residential cases are decided. A general open-access policy, a posted sign welcoming hikers, or tolerance of trespassers is permission, not an express invitation. A direct, personal invitation from the owner to a specific person to come use the property usually qualifies. Courts focus on whether the landowner personally and directly invited the plaintiff, and invitations conveyed through third parties or extended to the general public are typically treated as permission.
Develop the invitation evidence carefully: text messages, emails, social media posts, and the testimony of the person who extended the invitation. In social gatherings, determine who actually invited the plaintiff and whether that person had authority to do so on the owner's behalf.
Practice points
Section 846 is raised early, usually in a summary judgment motion, so the exception record should be built in the first months of the case. Interview the client and companions about how they came to be on the property, what they paid, and who invited them. Request the defendant's records of prior incidents, maintenance, and communications about the hazard. Plead the exceptions specifically in the complaint rather than waiting for the defense to raise the statute.
For related premises duty doctrines, see our premises liability coverage and the case law archive. Recreational use immunity is broad, but it is not absolute, and the exceptions are almost entirely fact-driven.










