Liens & Settlement

When the Client Disappears: Holding Settlement Funds, Paying Liens, and Unclaimed Property Rules

Every high-volume PI firm eventually has settlement money in trust for a client who stops responding.

Returned envelope marked undeliverable on a law office mail tray

Every high-volume PI firm eventually has settlement money in trust for a client who stops responding. What the firm can pay, what it must hold, how hard it must search, and when the funds go to the state.

It happens more often than firms like to admit. A case settles, the check clears, the liens are negotiated, and the client stops answering the phone. Letters come back undeliverable. The mobile number is disconnected. The client's share sits in the trust account month after month while providers call about their payments. The professional responsibility rules give a clear framework for these situations, but many firms handle them ad hoc, and that is where trust account problems begin.

First, separate two different situations

The client who disappears before settlement is a different problem from the client who disappears after. A lawyer cannot accept a settlement offer without the client's authority. If the client is unreachable while an offer is pending, the firm cannot simply accept and deposit the funds. The options are to keep trying to reach the client, request additional time from the carrier, and, if the client remains unreachable for an extended period and the representation cannot continue, consider withdrawal under the applicable rules while protecting the client's interests, including any approaching deadlines.

This article addresses the more common problem: the case has settled with the client's authority and signed release, the funds are in trust, and the client cannot be found for disbursement.

What the firm holds and for whom

Settlement proceeds in trust belong to different people. The attorney's fee and reimbursable costs belong to the firm once earned and undisputed. Amounts owed to lien holders belong, in practical effect, to those third parties if the firm has a legal obligation to them, whether by statute, by a signed lien or letter of protection, or by agreement. The client's net share belongs to the client.

Under rules modeled on ABA Model Rule 1.15, and California's Rule 1.15 in particular, a lawyer must promptly distribute undisputed funds to those entitled to them and must hold disputed funds in trust until the dispute is resolved. A missing client does not change who owns what. The firm may withdraw its earned fee and costs if the fee agreement and settlement authority support it. The firm may pay lien holders whose claims are undisputed and whose payment the client authorized, typically in the signed settlement statement or disbursement authorization. The client's share must remain in trust.

The hard cases are liens whose amount was not finally agreed before the client disappeared, or liens the client had disputed. Paying those without client authorization exposes the firm. If the lien is statutory, such as Medicare or a hospital lien perfected under state law, the obligation to satisfy it may not depend on client consent, and paying it protects both the client and the firm. For contractual and provider liens, review what the client signed before paying anything.

The search obligation

A lawyer holding a client's funds must make reasonable efforts to locate the client. What counts as reasonable depends on the amount and circumstances, but a documented search should include:

  • Letters by first-class and certified mail to every known address, including addresses from medical records and the intake file.
  • Calls and texts to every known number, including emergency contacts listed at intake.
  • Emails to every address in the file.
  • Searches of public records, social media, and paid locator databases.
  • Contact with family members or referral sources the client authorized the firm to speak with.
  • Checks of inmate locators and, sadly, obituary and probate records.

Document every step in the file with dates and results. If the client has died, the funds belong to the estate, and the firm must deal with the personal representative.

Unclaimed property

When the search fails, state unclaimed property laws eventually govern. Funds held for an owner who cannot be located, including client trust balances, generally must be reported and remitted to the state after a statutory dormancy period, which in many states is several years. California's Unclaimed Property Law applies to funds held by attorneys, and the State Controller's Office publishes reporting requirements and timelines. Reporting typically requires a due diligence notice to the owner's last known address before remittance.

Remitting funds to the state does not extinguish the client's right to them; the client can later claim them from the state. It does relieve the firm of the obligation to hold them indefinitely and reduces the risk that dormant balances become a trust accounting problem. Some state bars also have rules or programs for unidentified or unclaimed trust funds, so confirm the requirements in each jurisdiction where the firm holds trust accounts.

Preventing the problem

Most missing-client situations are preventable at intake. Collect multiple phone numbers, a personal email, a mailing address that is likely to remain stable, and at least two emergency contacts with written authority to share limited information. Update contact information at each case milestone. Discuss disbursement timing and the client's preferred payment method before the case settles, and have the client sign the settlement statement and disbursement authorization at the same meeting where the release is signed. Our practice operations coverage addresses trust accounting and intake checklists, and our liens and settlement archive covers disbursement sequencing. A disappearing client is a client service problem first and a compliance problem second, but the compliance part has to be handled exactly right.

Who LawyersTrend is for

Three ways in

Selling to the PI bar? See sponsor and advertiser options.