The settlement check has cleared, the client has signed the release, and the case manager is asking when the disbursement can go out. This is when a firm is most exposed. Every dollar in the trust account now belongs to someone, and a lien left out at closing doesn't go away. It comes back as a demand letter to the firm, a State Bar complaint, or in the worst case, a federal recovery action naming the lawyer who signed the checks.
Most lien problems at closing don't come from obscure statutes. They come from skipped steps: a conditional payment letter treated as a final demand, an ERISA plan assumed to be insured, a hospital notice sitting in a scanned-mail folder. The answer is a fixed audit that runs on every file before disbursement, whether the settlement is $15,000 or $1.5 million. Here are the ten lines.
Why the Audit Belongs at Closing, Not Intake
Lien work starts at intake, but intake lists go stale. Treatment continues, carriers change, Medi-Cal eligibility starts and stops, and a provider that billed the health plan in month two may have switched to a lien contract by month nine. The closing audit is not a repeat of intake. It checks the current state of every claim against the money now sitting in trust.
The duty behind it is Rule 1.15 of the California Rules of Professional Conduct. Funds held for a client and a third party must stay in trust, and when a third party's claim to those funds is disputed, the disputed portion stays in trust until the dispute is resolved. The undisputed portion has to go out promptly. The audit tells you which number is which.
Lines 1 Through 3: Inventory and Government Payers
Line 1: Rebuild the lien inventory from source documents
Don't work from the case management system's lien tab. Pull the full medical billing set, every explanation of benefits, the client's insurance cards, and the claims index report, then compare. Any payer on an EOB that isn't on your lien list is a gap. Ask the client directly, in writing, whether any other insurer, government program, or provider paid for treatment or has contacted them. Keep the answer in the file.
Line 2: Medicare final demand, not conditional payments
Under the Medicare Secondary Payer Act, 42 U.S.C. § 1395y(b)(2), Medicare's recovery right attaches to the settlement, and 42 C.F.R. § 411.24(g) lets the government recover from any entity that received the proceeds, including the plaintiff's attorney. A conditional payment letter is a running total, not a payoff figure. Report the settlement to the recovery contractor, get the final demand, and either pay it or file a formal dispute or waiver request before releasing any funds that could be needed to satisfy it. If the client is a Medicare beneficiary with future treatment, record in the file how future medicals were considered.
Line 3: Medi-Cal lien and the required notices
Medi-Cal's recovery right runs under Welfare and Institutions Code section 14124.70 and following. The statute imposes notice obligations on the attorney and gives a 25 percent reduction for attorney fees plus a pro rata share of costs under section 14124.72. Where the recovery doesn't fairly compensate the full damages, section 14124.76 lets you ask the court to reduce the lien, consistent with the allocation limits recognized in Arkansas Department of Health and Human Services v. Ahlborn (2006) 547 U.S. 268 and Gallardo v. Marstiller (2022) 596 U.S. 420. Get the final lien amount in writing from DHCS. A phone estimate is not a payoff. If the client will stay on means-tested benefits after settlement, the structure of the net proceeds matters as much as the lien; see our discussion of special needs trusts, pooled trusts, and ABLE accounts.
Lines 4 Through 6: Private Plans and Hospitals
Line 4: Confirm whether the health plan is self-funded ERISA
This is the line that hurts firms most often. A self-funded ERISA plan's reimbursement terms generally preempt California's anti-subrogation and reduction rules, and under US Airways, Inc. v. McCutchen (2013) 569 U.S. 88, clear plan language can override the common-fund doctrine. After Montanile v. Board of Trustees (2016) 577 U.S. 136, a plan can't pursue the client's general assets once the settlement funds are spent, which is exactly why plans move fast to reach identifiable funds still in your trust account. Request the governing plan document, not just the summary plan description, and check the plan's Form 5500 filing to see whether it is funded through insurance or out of the employer's general assets. Don't rely on the recovery vendor's word.
Line 5: Apply Civil Code section 3040 to non-ERISA plans
For insured plans and health care service plans that fall outside ERISA preemption and outside the government programs, Civil Code section 3040 caps the lien. Where the enrollee was represented, the lien can't exceed the lesser of the amount actually paid or one-third of the recovery, and it is reduced pro rata for attorney fees and costs. Many recovery vendors send demands that ignore section 3040 entirely. Run the math yourself, send a written section 3040 calculation, and hold the disputed difference in trust if the plan won't agree. For when that fight is worth taking to court, see health-plan lien disputes: when to litigate and when to negotiate.
Line 6: Hospital Lien Act claims
Under Civil Code section 3045.1 and following, a hospital that provided emergency and ongoing care can assert a lien against the recovery if it gave proper written notice. Section 3045.4 caps the combined hospital-lien recovery at a percentage of the amount paid. Confirm whether notice was actually served, whether the hospital also billed and was paid by a health plan for the same charges, and whether the cap applies when there are several lienholders. A hospital lien that was never perfected is a negotiating point, not an automatic payoff.
Lines 7 Through 9: Providers, Comp Carriers, and Other Claimants
Line 7: Contractual provider liens
Lien-based chiropractors, imaging centers, and surgery centers usually hold a signed lien agreement or letter of protection. Pull the actual document the client signed and confirm the balance against itemized billing, not a summary statement. Get every reduction in writing, signed by someone with authority, stating the amount accepted as payment in full.
Line 8: Workers' compensation liens and credits
If any part of the injury happened in the course of employment, the employer or comp carrier has rights under Labor Code sections 3856 and 3860, including a lien for benefits paid and a credit against future benefits. A third-party settlement without addressing the comp carrier can leave the client without future benefits and the firm facing a lien claim. Confirm the carrier's position and, where needed, get the comp claim resolved or the credit addressed in writing.
Line 9: Attorney liens, judgment creditors, and support liens
Check for a substituted-out prior counsel with a fee lien, a notice of lien filed in the action by a judgment creditor under Code of Civil Procedure section 708.410, and any child support lien asserted by a local child support agency. Prior counsel claims are their own subject; our piece on prior counsel fee liens and quantum meruit covers how to value and hold them. Keep in mind that a filed section 708.410 lien requires court approval or the creditor's written consent before you pay out the judgment debtor's share. For minors and incompetent adults, every lien and fee figure also has to match what the court approved in the compromise order.
Line 10: Reconcile the Trust Ledger Before the First Check
The last line is accounting, and it isn't optional. Confirm the settlement funds have actually cleared, not just been deposited. Build a closing statement that lists the gross recovery, fees, each cost item with backup, each lien at its final written amount, every amount held back in trust with the reason, and the client's net. The client signs it before disbursement. Match each lien line to a written payoff or reduction letter in the file. Any line without a letter is either held in trust or doesn't go out.
Then reconcile the client ledger against the account. Held-back amounts get their own ledger entries and a calendared follow-up date, because disputed funds that sit untouched in trust for years are their own compliance problem. When the dispute is resolved, disburse, document, and close the sub-ledger.
The Discipline Is the Protection
None of these ten lines is complicated. The risk comes from skipping one because the case is small, the client is impatient, or the vendor's letter looked final. Run the same audit every time, in the same order, with a written sign-off from the attorney who controls the trust account. The firms that never get the Medicare letter addressed to the lawyer, or the ERISA complaint naming the firm, aren't lucky. They just never disburse until all ten lines are cleared.










