Most of the attention in Medicare secondary payer practice goes to the conditional payment stage: requesting the conditional payment letter, disputing unrelated charges, and getting the itemization right before settlement. That work matters, but it is not the last opportunity to reduce what the client pays back. After settlement is reported, the Benefits Coordination and Recovery Center issues a final demand. From that point, the beneficiary has three separate paths to reduce the recovery: a formal appeal, a waiver request, and a compromise request. Each has its own legal basis, decision-maker, and evidentiary demands, and they are frequently confused.
Start with the clock
The final demand sets two deadlines that drive everything else. Payment is due within 60 days, and interest accrues from the date of the demand if it is not paid in that window. Separately, the beneficiary has 120 days from receipt of the demand to request a redetermination, the first level of administrative appeal. Filing an appeal or a waiver request does not stop interest from accruing. For that reason, many practitioners pay the demand in full within 60 days, holding the disputed amount in reserve with the client's informed consent, and then pursue the appeal or waiver for a refund. Others hold the funds in trust and accept the interest risk. Either way, the decision should be documented in the client file before day 60.
Path one: appeal the amount
An appeal challenges whether Medicare is entitled to the amount demanded. It is the right tool when the dispute is about the claims themselves: charges for treatment unrelated to the injury, dates of service outside the injury period, duplicate claims, or an error in the procurement cost reduction. The appeal proceeds through redetermination by the recovery contractor, reconsideration by a qualified independent contractor, a hearing before an administrative law judge, review by the Medicare Appeals Council, and, if the amount in controversy is met, judicial review.
Appeals succeed on records. The submission should identify each disputed claim line, explain why it is unrelated, and attach a treating physician's statement or the medical records that establish the distinction. A general argument that the client had pre-existing conditions rarely moves the reviewer; a line-by-line chart tied to diagnosis codes often does.
Path two: request a waiver
A waiver does not dispute the amount. It asks Medicare to forgo recovery, in whole or in part, under Section 1870(c) of the Social Security Act. The beneficiary must show that he or she was without fault and that recovery would either defeat the purpose of the Medicare program, typically because it would cause financial hardship, or would be against equity and good conscience.
Financial hardship waivers require a detailed financial disclosure: income, assets, monthly expenses, and why repayment would leave the beneficiary unable to meet ordinary and necessary living expenses. Equity and good conscience arguments are fact-specific and work best when the settlement is small relative to the injury, when future medical needs will consume the net recovery, or when liability or coverage problems forced a compromise well below the case's full value. Supporting evidence includes the policy limits declaration, the damages analysis, and documentation of anticipated future care.
Waiver decisions denying relief are themselves subject to the appeal process, so the waiver request should be built as a record from the start, not as a letter.
Path three: request a compromise
A compromise asks Medicare to accept less than the full amount owed in exchange for prompt payment. Compromise authority belongs to CMS rather than the contractor, and requests are considered on factors such as the litigation risk the beneficiary faced, the costs of collection, and the beneficiary's ability to pay. Unlike a waiver, a compromise does not require a showing that the beneficiary would suffer hardship, but it is discretionary and not appealable. It is often used when a case settled for a fraction of its value because of limited coverage and the beneficiary cannot meet the stricter waiver standard.
Practitioners differ on sequencing. A common approach is to resolve any appeal of the amount first, because a waiver or compromise calculated on an inflated demand starts from the wrong number, then pursue waiver, and treat compromise as a fallback. Where hardship is clear and the amount is not in dispute, going directly to waiver is often faster.
Small settlements
Two features of the program help at the low end. CMS does not pursue recovery on certain liability settlements below its annual low-dollar threshold, currently $750 for physical trauma-based liability settlements. And for qualifying settlements of $5,000 or less, the fixed percentage option allows the beneficiary to elect to repay 25 percent of the total settlement in lieu of the conditional payment amount, provided the election is made before Medicare issues its demand. Both should be evaluated before the case is reported as settled.
Client communication
Clients rarely understand why money is being held after the case closes. A short written explanation of the final demand, the chosen path, and the expected timeline prevents most complaints. Our practice operations archive covers post-settlement client communication, and our liens and settlement coverage addresses conditional payment disputes before the demand is issued. The final demand is not the end of the negotiation; it is the beginning of a separate one with different rules.










