Jurisprudencia y acuerdos

Knight v. Jewett y su jurisprudencia posterior: cómo vencer la asunción primaria del riesgo en casos de recreación

La asunción primaria del riesgo es una doctrina de ausencia de deber, y pone fin a los casos de lesiones recreativas en el juicio sumario.

Campo de un parque recreativo vacío con un balón de fútbol americano sobre el pasto

Este artículo todavía no está disponible en español. Abajo está la versión original en inglés; la traducción revisada se publicará pronto.

La asunción primaria del riesgo es una doctrina de ausencia de deber, y pone fin a los casos de lesiones recreativas en el juicio sumario. Knight, Kahn, Shin y Nalwa definen dónde termina y dónde los operadores y entrenadores aún tienen un deber.

Recreation injury cases share a predictable arc in California. The plaintiff is hurt on a ski slope, at a trampoline park, during a pickup basketball game, or on an amusement ride. The defense answers with primary assumption of risk, moves for summary judgment, and argues that the defendant owed no duty to protect against a risk inherent in the activity. Whether the case survives depends on how well plaintiff counsel understands the doctrine set out in Knight v. Jewett (1992) 3 Cal.4th 296 and refined in the decisions that followed it.

The holding in Knight

Knight arose from a touch football game at a Super Bowl party. The plaintiff told the defendant to stop playing so roughly; on the next play, the defendant knocked her down and stepped on her hand, causing an injury that eventually required amputation of a finger. The California Supreme Court affirmed summary judgment for the defendant. The lead opinion reframed assumption of risk after the adoption of comparative fault in Li v. Yellow Cab. It divided the doctrine into two categories. Secondary assumption of risk, where the defendant owes a duty but the plaintiff knowingly encounters a risk created by the breach, is merged into comparative fault and goes to the jury. Primary assumption of risk, where the nature of the activity and the parties' relationship mean the defendant owes no duty to protect against a particular risk, is a complete bar.

For co-participants in an active sport, the lead opinion held that the duty is limited. A participant breaches a duty only by intentionally injuring another player or by engaging in conduct so reckless as to be totally outside the range of ordinary activity involved in the sport. Ordinary carelessness during play, even rough play, is an inherent risk.

The decisive point for practitioners is that primary assumption of risk is a question of duty, decided by the court based on the nature of the activity and the defendant's role. The plaintiff's subjective knowledge and consent do not control. That makes the doctrine an early and powerful defense tool.

The progeny: how the doctrine was extended and limited

Knight was a plurality opinion, but the Supreme Court adopted its framework in later cases and applied it to a range of defendants.

  • Kahn v. East Side Union High School Dist. (2003) 31 Cal.4th 990. A high school swimmer was injured diving into a shallow racing pool after her coach pressured her to dive despite her fear and lack of training. The court held that a coach or instructor breaches a duty only by intentionally injuring the student or by engaging in conduct totally outside the range of ordinary instruction, but it reversed summary judgment because the record supported an inference of recklessness. Kahn is the primary authority for cases against coaches and instructors.
  • Shin v. Ahn (2007) 42 Cal.4th 482. A golfer struck by a ball hit by a playing partner. The court held that golf is an active sport subject to the doctrine, but remanded because fact questions remained about whether the defendant's conduct, including where the plaintiff was standing and whether the defendant checked, was reckless.
  • Nalwa v. Cedar Fair, L.P. (2012) 55 Cal.4th 1148. A bumper car rider fractured her wrist. The court extended primary assumption of risk beyond competitive sports to recreational activities generally, holding that the operator had no duty to eliminate the bumping that was the point of the ride.

Read together, those decisions establish that the doctrine reaches co-participants, coaches, and operators, and that it reaches recreation broadly. They also establish its limits.

Where the plaintiff wins

Three lines of argument defeat summary judgment most reliably.

Increased risk

Operators, owners, and organizers owe a duty not to increase the risks inherent in the activity beyond those already present. A ski resort need not remove moguls, but it may be liable for an unmarked man-made obstacle. A trampoline park need not prevent all collisions, but it may be liable for allowing adults and small children to jump on the same mat, or for worn padding over the frame. Frame the theory around what the defendant added to or failed to maintain in the activity's design, not around the inherent risk itself.

Recklessness

Where the defendant is a co-participant or instructor, the claim survives only on recklessness or intent, but recklessness is often a fact question. Kahn and Shin both reversed or remanded on that basis. Develop evidence that the conduct was outside the range of the activity: rule violations that serve safety purposes, conduct after play stopped, or instruction that disregarded known limitations of the student.

The risk was not inherent

Defendants frequently define the activity broadly to bring the injury within it. Push back on the characterization. Being struck by a falling light fixture at a gym is not an inherent risk of exercise. A collision caused by defective equipment is not an inherent risk of the sport. The court's duty analysis depends on how precisely the risk is defined, and that definition is contestable.

Practice points

Primary assumption of risk is usually raised in a motion, not at trial, so the duty record has to exist by the time of the opposition. Retain an industry expert early to testify about how the activity is normally conducted and what operators customarily do to minimize risk. Obtain the defendant's own safety rules, staff training materials, and incident history; those documents often show that the defendant itself regarded the risk as one it could and should control. Address any express release separately, because waivers and primary assumption of risk are distinct defenses with different limits, and a release does not bar claims for gross negligence.

For related premises authority, see our premises liability coverage, and for other duty decisions that shape early motion practice, see the case law archive. Knight is three decades old, but it still decides more recreation cases at the pleading and summary judgment stage than any other California decision. The cases that survive it are the ones built around increased risk, recklessness, or a precise definition of what the activity actually involves.

Para quién es LawyersTrend

Tres formas de empezar

¿Vende a abogados de lesiones personales? Vea las opciones para patrocinadores y anunciantes.