Jurisprudencia y acuerdos

Berk v. Choy: las leyes estatales de declaración jurada de mérito no se aplican en tribunales federales

The Supreme Court held in January 2026 that Delaware's medical malpractice affidavit-of-merit requirement does not apply to a diversity…

Columnas exteriores del edificio de la Corte Suprema de los Estados Unidos en un día nublado

Este artículo todavía no está disponible en español. Abajo está la versión original en inglés; la traducción revisada se publicará pronto.

The Supreme Court held in January 2026 that Delaware's medical malpractice affidavit-of-merit requirement does not apply to a diversity case in federal court. Ten months later, the forum strategy implications for med-mal plaintiffs are coming into focus.

Roughly half the states require a medical malpractice plaintiff to file an affidavit or certificate of merit, typically a statement from a qualified health care professional that the claim has a reasonable basis, either with the complaint or shortly after. For years, federal courts sitting in diversity split on whether those requirements applied to state-law malpractice claims filed in federal court. In Berk v. Choy, No. 24-440, decided January 20, 2026, the Supreme Court resolved the question: Delaware's affidavit-of-merit statute does not apply in federal court, because the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure govern what a complaint must contain.

The facts and the lower courts

Harold Berk sued a physician and a hospital in the United States District Court for the District of Delaware, invoking diversity jurisdiction and alleging negligent treatment of an ankle injury. Delaware law requires a medical negligence plaintiff to file, with the complaint, an affidavit of merit signed by a qualified expert. Berk did not file one. The district court dismissed the claims, and the Third Circuit affirmed, treating the affidavit requirement as substantive state law that a federal court sitting in diversity must apply under the Erie doctrine.

The Supreme Court's holding

The Supreme Court reversed in an opinion by Justice Barrett. The analysis followed the framework from Shady Grove Orthopedic Associates v. Allstate Insurance Co. (2010): when a Federal Rule of Civil Procedure answers the question in dispute, the Federal Rule governs as long as it is valid under the Rules Enabling Act, and the Erie inquiry into whether the state law is substantive or procedural never begins. The Court concluded that the Federal Rules, beginning with Rule 8's requirement of a short and plain statement of the claim, establish what a plaintiff must do to state a claim and survive at the pleading stage. Delaware's statute imposes an additional requirement, a supporting expert affidavit, that the Federal Rules do not. Because the Federal Rules answer the question of what a complaint must include, the state requirement cannot be applied in federal court.

Berk resolved a circuit conflict. The Fourth Circuit had already reached the same result in Pledger v. Lynch, 5 F.4th 511 (4th Cir. 2021), declining to apply West Virginia's certificate-of-merit requirement in a federal case, while other circuits, including the Third, had applied state affidavit laws.

How broadly it reaches

The opinion addressed Delaware's statute, but most commentators read its reasoning to reach affidavit-of-merit and certificate-of-merit requirements generally, because those statutes share the same basic structure: an expert-supported filing required at or near the start of the case as a condition of proceeding. Federal courts have already begun applying Berk outside the medical context. A federal district court in Maryland applied it to claims against design professionals, holding that a state certificate-of-merit requirement for those claims did not apply in federal court.

The decision leaves other questions open. Many states have pre-suit requirements that differ from affidavits of merit, such as notice-of-intent periods, mandatory screening panels, and pre-suit expert disclosure. Defendants will argue that some of those provisions are substantive conditions on the cause of action rather than pleading rules, and that they survive Berk. Damages caps and statutes of limitation, which are substantive under long-standing Erie doctrine, are unaffected. Plaintiffs should not assume that every state-law hurdle to a malpractice claim disappears in federal court.

What Berk does not change

Berk addresses what a complaint must include. It does not change the plaintiff's burden of proof. A medical malpractice plaintiff in federal court still needs qualified expert testimony on the standard of care and causation, still must disclose experts under Rule 26, and still faces Rule 702 challenges to those experts and summary judgment if the expert record is inadequate. The practical effect is to remove an early procedural tripwire, not to lower the bar on the merits. Cases that would have failed for lack of expert support will still fail, just later.

Forum strategy after Berk

The decision changes the calculus for cases that can be filed in federal court. Diversity jurisdiction requires complete diversity and an amount in controversy over $75,000, which many malpractice cases meet when the defendant physician or hospital is in a different state from the plaintiff. Cases involving out-of-state providers, telehealth encounters across state lines, and patients who traveled for treatment are the most likely to qualify. Filing in federal court can avoid an affidavit deadline that would otherwise force early expert retention, particularly when the limitations period is close and medical records are incomplete.

That advantage must be weighed against others. Federal juries, judges, scheduling, and Rule 702 practice differ from state court, and those differences may matter more than the affidavit requirement. Defendants may also remove some cases to federal court on their own, and Berk will affect how affidavit defenses are handled after removal. Plaintiff counsel should evaluate the forum question case by case rather than treat Berk as a reason to file every eligible case in federal court.

Practice points

  • In a federal malpractice case, do not concede an affidavit-of-merit defense; cite Berk and move to strike or oppose dismissal.
  • In removed cases, evaluate whether a pending affidavit deadline still matters and raise Berk promptly.
  • Continue to retain qualified experts early; Berk removes a filing requirement, not the need for expert support.
  • Track federal decisions on notice-of-intent and screening panel statutes, which are the next likely area of litigation.

Our medical malpractice archive covers expert sourcing and certificate-of-merit practice in state court, and our case law coverage will follow lower-court decisions applying Berk as they develop.

Para quién es LawyersTrend

Tres formas de empezar

¿Vende a abogados de lesiones personales? Vea las opciones para patrocinadores y anunciantes.