Truck & Motorcycle

Rider Bias in the Jury Box: Voir Dire Strategy for Motorcycle Crash Trials

Many jurors arrive believing motorcyclists are reckless and assume the risk of injury every time they ride.

Motorcycle helmet resting on a courtroom counsel table

Many jurors arrive believing motorcyclists are reckless and assume the risk of injury every time they ride. Motorcycle trials are often decided in jury selection, and the questions have to surface that bias without reinforcing it.

Motorcycle crash cases carry a burden that most auto cases do not. Before any evidence is heard, a meaningful share of the jury pool holds views about riders that work against the plaintiff: that motorcyclists speed, weave through traffic, and accept the risk of serious injury every time they ride. Defense counsel know this and often build their case around it, emphasizing lane position, speed estimates, and the rider's gear even where the physical evidence points elsewhere. For plaintiff counsel, the jury selection process is where that bias must be identified and, where possible, removed.

Why rider bias is different

Most juror attitudes in personal injury cases are general: skepticism of lawsuits, concerns about damages, distrust of lawyers. Motorcycle bias is specific and often rooted in personal experience. Jurors may have been startled by a rider passing between lanes, may have a family member who was injured riding, or may simply have absorbed the cultural image of riders as risk-takers. Those experiences produce strong beliefs that jurors may not recognize as bias. A juror who says, "I think anyone who rides a motorcycle is asking for trouble," has told you something important. A juror who says, "I can be fair," may still believe it without saying so.

The legal consequence is that rider bias tends to show up in comparative fault allocations and damages rather than in the liability verdict itself. A jury may find the driver who turned left in front of the rider negligent, then assign a substantial share of fault to the rider based on assumptions about speed, or discount damages because the rider chose a dangerous mode of transportation.

Supplemental questionnaires

Where the court permits, a written juror questionnaire is the most efficient way to identify rider attitudes. Jurors answer more candidly in writing than in open court, and the questionnaire gives counsel time to plan follow-up questioning. Useful topics include:

  • Whether the juror or a family member has ever ridden or owned a motorcycle.
  • Whether the juror has had a close call or collision with a motorcycle while driving.
  • Whether anyone close to the juror has been injured or killed in a motorcycle crash, and how the juror views that event.
  • Whether the juror agrees or disagrees with statements such as "Motorcyclists are more reckless than other drivers" and "People who ride motorcycles accept the risk of being injured."
  • The juror's views on lane splitting, where it is legal in the jurisdiction, and on helmet use.

Scaled agreement questions are especially useful because they give jurors permission to express a view without being labeled as biased.

Oral voir dire technique

In open questioning, the goal is to get jurors talking, not to lecture them. Start by acknowledging the attitude directly: "Some people have strong feelings about motorcycles. Some love them, and some think they are dangerous. Where are you on that?" Open-ended questions draw out the jurors who hold strong views, and other jurors often follow their lead in speaking up. When a juror expresses a negative view, ask follow-up questions that explore it rather than challenge it: where the view comes from, how strongly it is held, and whether it would affect how the juror evaluates a rider's conduct.

Avoid questions that invite jurors to promise impartiality before their views have been explored. A juror who has just described a near miss with a motorcycle and is then asked whether he can be fair will usually say yes. The record for a cause challenge is built by having the juror explain the strength and source of the belief and acknowledge that it would make it hard to start the rider on equal footing with the driver.

Cause challenges and rehabilitation

Defense counsel and the court will often try to rehabilitate a juror who expresses rider bias. Prepare for that by building a record in the juror's own words before the rehabilitation question is asked. Statements such as "I would probably assume he was going too fast" or "I would need to be convinced he wasn't doing something wrong" are the language of a juror who would shift the burden of proof. Preserve peremptory challenges for jurors who show bias but survive cause challenges, and track the defense's use of peremptories against riders or rider-friendly jurors.

Identifying favorable jurors

Jurors with riding experience can be valuable, but not uniformly. Experienced riders often understand conspicuity problems, the physics of braking, and the reality that drivers frequently fail to see motorcycles. Some, however, hold other riders to an exacting standard and can be harder on a plaintiff than non-riders are. Ask riders about their own safety practices and how they view riders who do things differently.

Carrying the themes into trial

What jurors say in voir dire should shape the opening statement. If the panel expressed concern about speed, address the speed evidence early and concretely. If jurors focused on helmets, explain what the helmet evidence does and does not show about causation. Our motorcycle and trucking litigation archive covers comparative fault and helmet defense issues in more depth, and our practice operations coverage addresses trial preparation workflows. Motorcycle cases are often lost before opening statements begin. Careful jury selection is how they are kept alive.

Who LawyersTrend is for

Three ways in

Selling to the PI bar? See sponsor and advertiser options.