An uninsured motorist claim looks simple at intake. The other driver had no insurance, the client has UM coverage, and the claim is made against the client's own carrier. In California, though, the claim does not proceed like a third-party case. It is governed by Insurance Code section 11580.2, which requires arbitration of contested UM claims, imposes a strict two-year requirement that is unrelated to the ordinary statute of limitations, and divides authority between the arbitrator and the court in ways that catch practitioners who handle UM claims only occasionally.
The two-year requirement
Section 11580.2(i) is the most consequential provision in the statute. Within two years from the date of the accident, the insured must do one of three things: file suit against the uninsured motorist in a court of competent jurisdiction, reach an agreement with the carrier on the amount due, or formally institute arbitration proceedings by notifying the insurer in writing. If none of those occurs within the two-year period, the UM claim is generally barred.
The trap is that a demand letter, an exchange of medical records, or ongoing negotiations with the UM adjuster are not enough. Formal institution of arbitration requires a written notice that clearly invokes arbitration. Many firms send a short, unambiguous letter demanding arbitration under section 11580.2 at the same time they open the UM claim, regardless of where negotiations stand, and calendar the two-year date as a hard deadline in the same way they calendar a statute of limitations. The statute contains limited tolling provisions, including for certain carrier insolvency situations, but counsel should not rely on tolling to rescue a missed deadline.
Filing suit against the uninsured driver also satisfies the requirement, and it can be useful when the driver may have assets or when another defendant, such as a vehicle owner or employer, may have coverage that the investigation has not yet confirmed.
What the arbitrator decides and what the court decides
The UM arbitrator decides two questions: whether the insured is legally entitled to recover damages from the uninsured motorist, and the amount of those damages. That covers liability, comparative fault, causation, and damages. It does not cover coverage questions. Whether the claimant is an insured under the policy, whether the other vehicle was in fact uninsured, whether a policy exclusion applies, and whether the insured complied with policy conditions are generally questions for the court, not the arbitrator.
That division has strategic consequences. If the carrier raises a coverage defense, such as a dispute over residency for a relative claimant or an argument that another policy applies, counsel may need a declaratory relief action or a petition to resolve the coverage issue before the arbitration can produce a collectible award. Identify coverage disputes early, because an arbitration award on damages does not resolve them.
Discovery rights
UM arbitration is not informal. Section 11580.2(f) provides that the parties have discovery rights under the Code of Civil Procedure, which means interrogatories, document requests, depositions, independent medical examinations, and expert exchanges are available to both sides, and discovery disputes can be taken to the superior court. Carriers routinely use those tools, including depositions of the insured and treating providers and defense medical examinations. Plaintiff counsel should use them as well, particularly to depose the carrier's retained medical examiner and to obtain the claim file materials relevant to the valuation of damages.
Expect the carrier to treat the case the way a defense firm would. Many UM arbitrations are defended by panel counsel who also handle third-party litigation. The fact that the carrier is the client's own insurer does not soften the defense of the damages claim.
Selecting the arbitrator and preparing for hearing
The statute permits the parties to agree on a single neutral arbitrator. Most UM arbitrations proceed that way, often before a retired judge or experienced practitioner from a private ADR provider. Arbitrator selection matters as much as venue selection in a jury case. Look at the arbitrator's background, the types of cases the arbitrator has heard, and, where available, prior UM awards.
Hearing preparation should mirror trial preparation, scaled to the forum. Prepare a concise hearing brief, exhibit binders with medical summaries and billing, and live or video testimony from the client and key treating physicians. Arbitrators read the materials, so a clear medical chronology and damages summary often carries more weight than it would with a jury.
Underinsured claims and exhaustion
Underinsured motorist claims follow the same arbitration framework but add an exhaustion requirement: the UIM claim generally may not proceed until the limits of all applicable liability bonds or policies have been exhausted by judgment or settlement, and the carrier is entitled to credit for the amounts paid by the liability insurer. Consent-to-settle issues arise at that stage and must be handled before accepting the liability limits. Our auto accident archive covers consent and stacking questions in detail.
After the award
A UM award may be confirmed, corrected, or vacated through the superior court under the arbitration statutes. Once paid, the carrier may pursue reimbursement from the uninsured driver, and lien holders will expect to be addressed from the recovery. Our liens and settlement coverage discusses how health plan and provider liens are handled when the recovery comes from first-party coverage. The procedural rules are not complicated, but they are strict. The two-year notice letter is the single most important document in the file.










