Noticias del sector

Lesiones personales esta semana: un veredicto de $24M en radiología, un fallo de unanimidad en Illinois y el litigio de AFFF después de 3M

A South Carolina jury finds a radiologist grossly negligent, an Illinois appellate panel clarifies what jurors must agree on in a…

Palco del jurado de una sala de tribunal vacía bajo una suave luz de la tarde

Este artículo todavía no está disponible en español. Abajo está la versión original en inglés; la traducción revisada se publicará pronto.

A South Carolina jury finds a radiologist grossly negligent, an Illinois appellate panel clarifies what jurors must agree on in a multi-failure med-mal case, and the AFFF MDL resets its next bellwether clock as holdout defendants stay in mediation.

The week before Thanksgiving tends to be quiet on trial calendars, but the past seven days produced a set of rulings and docket moves that matter more for case-building than for headlines. A South Carolina jury returned a large wrongful death verdict against a radiologist, an Illinois appellate court addressed a jury unanimity question that comes up in nearly every multi-defendant birth injury case, and the AFFF multidistrict litigation reorganized its schedule around the 3M deal. Here is what plaintiff practitioners should take from each.

Columbia jury: $24 million against a radiologist for a missed perforation

A Columbia, South Carolina jury awarded $24 million to the estate of a 36-year-old father and decorated F-16 pilot who died after complications from a heart procedure, according to reporting by Radiology Business and other outlets on November 11. The jury found that a radiologist failed to identify an esophageal perforation on a CT angiogram and found the radiologist grossly negligent. The estate had previously settled with the cardiologist for $1.2 million.

Three points stand out for med-mal practitioners. First, the verdict is a reminder that the reading physician is often the most exposed defendant in a procedural complication case, even when the procedure itself was performed by someone else. The imaging study is a fixed, reviewable record, and a retrospective read by a plaintiff's expert can be presented to a jury in a way that a disputed bedside judgment cannot. Second, the gross negligence finding matters in jurisdictions where that standard affects caps, apportionment, or immunity defenses. Plaintiff counsel building imaging cases should consider pleading gross negligence where the miss was on a study ordered specifically to look for the complication. Third, the gap between the $1.2 million early settlement and the verdict will be studied by defense carriers deciding how early to resolve the clinically central defendant. It is also a cautionary data point for plaintiffs on how settlement credits and empty-chair arguments play out when a co-defendant leaves the case before trial.

Post-trial motions are expected, and the verdict amount may change. Practitioners citing it in demands should track the final judgment rather than the jury number.

Illinois appellate court: jurors need not agree on which failure caused the injury

On November 16, an Illinois appellate panel affirmed a $7.5 million verdict against Advocate Medical Group in a childbirth death case, according to a Law360 report. The court held that jurors must agree that negligence caused the injury but need not agree on which specific negligent act or omission caused it.

That holding addresses a recurring defense tactic. In obstetric cases, plaintiffs usually present several alleged breaches: failure to recognize a non-reassuring fetal heart tracing, failure to escalate to the attending, failure to call for a timely cesarean, and failure to manage postpartum complications. Defense counsel often argue that a general verdict cannot stand unless the jury was required to agree on a single causal failure, and they press for special interrogatories that break the case into pieces. The Illinois ruling treats the combination of breaches as a single negligence theory for unanimity purposes, which is how most clinical failures actually unfold.

Plaintiff counsel outside Illinois should not assume the same rule applies at home. Jury instruction law on unanimity and special verdicts varies, and some states require specificity when distinct acts are attributed to different defendants. But the opinion is useful persuasive authority when resisting verdict forms designed to fracture a cohesive clinical narrative. It also supports a trial strategy that presents the chain of failures as one story rather than a list of independent errors.

AFFF MDL: the bellwether clock moves after the 3M deal

Two weeks after 3M announced its $7.35 billion nominal settlement of personal injury claims in the AFFF litigation, MDL 2873 in the District of South Carolina is reorganizing around the deal. According to docket trackers, Case Management Order 26P, entered November 13, moved the deadline for Group B personal injury bellwether proposals, covering case selection and expert discovery, from November 20, 2026 to March 19, 2027. Several sources also report that the claimant identification list for the 3M program closed on November 13.

For firms with AFFF inventory, the practical questions are now about the defendants who have not settled. DuPont reported about 13,700 personal injury cases in the MDL as of September 30 and has said it continues to negotiate with a mediator. Plaintiffs who reject the 3M terms generally face records and expert report deadlines, reported as 60 and 120 days, which means opt-out decisions require a realistic look at whether each client can meet causation expert requirements on a compressed schedule. The extension of the Group B schedule gives the remaining defendants time to negotiate, and gives plaintiff leadership leverage that did not exist before 3M committed. Firms should be auditing their inventories now for disease category, exposure documentation, and lien status, because those factors will drive allocation if a second global deal follows.

Our liens and settlement coverage has addressed the mass tort lien resolution process; with a nine-year payment structure on the 3M side, lien sequencing and Medicare reporting will be a sustained administrative burden rather than a one-time closing task.

Roundup: the post-Durnell cleanup continues

In the Roundup MDL, docket trackers listed a federal hearing on November 16 on Monsanto's first dismissal motions premised on the Supreme Court's Durnell decision, which held that FIFRA preempts state failure-to-warn claims. The motions test how much of the remaining inventory can survive on design defect and other non-label theories. Plaintiffs who pleaded only failure to warn are the most exposed; firms that built complaints around design and manufacturing theories, or around claims that do not depend on label content, are in a stronger position. The rulings that come out of this round will shape whether the remaining federal Roundup docket is a settlement problem or a dismissal problem.

Social media litigation: private claims stay live

The consent judgment between Meta and 51 state attorneys general, entered in August, does not release the private personal injury claims pending in the social media adolescent addiction MDL. Trackers report that the settlement agreement expressly carves those claims out, and that the next school district bellwether trial is set for February 8, 2027. For firms holding individual adolescent injury cases, the takeaway is that the government resolution neither caps nor resolves those claims, though defendants will likely cite its injunctive terms as evidence of changed conduct in punitive damages arguments.

Talc: a partial result in Massachusetts

A Massachusetts jury ordered Johnson & Johnson to pay $1.9 million on a mesothelioma claim, though reports indicate jurors did not find the company liable for the death itself. Split results like this one are worth reading closely. They show juries drawing distinctions between exposure, product defect, and causation of death, and they offer a preview of how defendants will frame damages in the remaining individual talc trials.

What to watch next week

The holiday week will thin the trial calendar, but motion practice and settlement conferences tend to accelerate as carriers try to close reserves before year end. Firms with cases in mediation should expect adjusters to push for December resolutions, and should prepare updated damages packages and lien summaries now so that a year-end offer can be evaluated quickly. Several items are worth tracking:

  • Post-trial motions in the South Carolina radiology verdict, including any challenge to the gross negligence finding.
  • Whether the Advocate defendants seek further review of the Illinois unanimity ruling.
  • Additional rulings on Durnell-based dismissal motions in the Roundup MDL.
  • Any announcement from DuPont or other AFFF defendants on mediation progress before the March 2027 bellwether deadline.

For appellate developments as they land, follow our case law and settlements coverage.

Para quién es LawyersTrend

Tres formas de empezar

¿Vende a abogados de lesiones personales? Vea las opciones para patrocinadores y anunciantes.