Practice Operations

Measuring Case Cycle Time at the PI Firm: Stage-by-Stage Metrics That Change Behavior

Average days from intake to disbursement hides where cases actually stall.

Law office whiteboard with a hand-drawn case pipeline and sticky notes

Average days from intake to disbursement hides where cases actually stall. Breaking cycle time into stages, measuring medians, and assigning owners turns a vanity number into an operating tool.

Most PI firms can say, roughly, how long their cases take. Fewer can say where the time goes. A firm average of fourteen months from signup to disbursement tells a managing partner almost nothing about whether the delay sits in treatment, in records collection, in demand preparation, in negotiation, or in the weeks after settlement when lien resolution and paperwork drag on. Cycle time becomes useful only when it is broken into stages, measured consistently, and assigned to the people who control each stage.

Define the stages before you measure

The first decision is which milestones mark the boundaries between stages. They should be events the case management system already records with a date, or can easily be configured to record. A workable pre-litigation model for most firms looks like this:

  • Intake to treatment established: signed retainer to first confirmed treating appointment.
  • Treatment phase: first appointment to treatment completion or a documented decision to proceed while treatment continues.
  • Records and bills: treatment completion to all records and itemized bills received.
  • Demand preparation: records complete to demand sent.
  • Negotiation: demand sent to settlement or decision to file.
  • Settlement to disbursement: settlement agreed to client funds disbursed.

Litigated files need their own stages, typically complaint to answer, written discovery, depositions, expert designation, and mediation or trial. Keep litigated and pre-litigation cases in separate reports. Combining them produces numbers nobody can act on.

Use medians and distributions, not averages

PI case durations are skewed. A handful of catastrophic files that take four years will pull an average far above what a typical case experiences. Report the median for each stage, and add the 75th and 90th percentiles to show how long the slow cases take. The gap between the median and the 90th percentile is often more revealing than either number alone, because it shows whether a stage has a consistent process or a long tail of neglected files.

Segment by case type as well. Soft-tissue auto cases, premises cases, and surgical cases have different natural treatment durations, and comparing them against a single benchmark penalizes the people handling the harder files.

Separate controllable time from waiting time

Some stages depend mostly on outside parties. Treatment length is driven by the client's medical course. Negotiation length depends partly on the adjuster. Records collection depends on providers. But each of those stages also contains controllable time: the days between a provider's response and the next follow-up request, the time a completed records set sits before a demand writer picks it up, and the days between a settlement agreement and the firm's request for the release.

The most productive metrics isolate that internal time. Two examples that tend to change behavior quickly are days from records complete to demand sent, and days from settlement agreed to release and lien payoffs requested. Both are almost entirely within the firm's control, and both commonly stretch for weeks without anyone noticing.

Assign an owner to each stage

A metric without an owner is a report, not a management tool. Each stage should belong to a role: case managers for treatment and records, demand writers or associates for demand preparation, negotiators for the negotiation stage, and settlement or trust accounting staff for disbursement. Owners should review their stage report weekly and be able to explain any file above the 90th percentile. That review does not need to be punitive. In most firms, the first few weeks of stage reporting surface process gaps, such as a records request template that providers routinely reject, rather than individual performance problems.

Watch for metric gaming

Any measured stage can be shortened in ways that hurt case value. A demand sent before records are complete shortens demand preparation but weakens the demand. A settlement accepted to clear the negotiation queue shortens cycle time at the client's expense. Pair cycle time metrics with outcome measures, such as net to client and demand-to-settlement ratio by case type, so that speed and value are reviewed together.

Starting small

Firms without clean milestone data should not wait for a perfect system. Pick two stages, configure the case management system to capture the start and end dates reliably, and run the report monthly for one quarter. The settlement-to-disbursement stage is a good first choice because it is fully internal and directly affects client satisfaction. Clients who wait two months after hearing that their case settled call the office repeatedly, post reviews, and occasionally file bar complaints, so shortening that window pays off in reduced phone volume as well as goodwill. Share the first quarter's results with the whole team, including the files that ran longest and why. Our liens and settlement coverage addresses the lien resolution steps that usually dominate that stage, and our practice operations archive covers software and staffing choices that support stage reporting.

Cycle time is not the goal. Fair recoveries, delivered without avoidable delay, are the goal. Stage metrics simply make the avoidable part visible.

Who LawyersTrend is for

Three ways in

Selling to the PI bar? See sponsor and advertiser options.