Industry News

Personal Injury Verdict Wrap: $28M Cook County Verdict, Fee Fights, Recalls

A $28M Cook County med-mal verdict and a reported $21.9M garbage-truck case anchor the week, while Chong v.

Personal Injury Verdict Wrap: $28M Cook County Verdict, Fee Fights, Recalls

A $28M Cook County med-mal verdict and a reported $21.9M garbage-truck case anchor the week, while Chong v. Mardirossian Akaragian and SB 623's lien-sale disclosure rule reshape how firms and providers track fee and lien exposure heading into 2027.

Verdicts: Cook County Med-Mal Hits $28M, Garbage-Truck Case Tops $21M

A Cook County, Illinois jury returned a $28 million verdict on November 5 in the case brought by Teray Boyd against University of Illinois Hospital, arising from a delayed cesarean section during a December 2023 labor and delivery. Plaintiff counsel and the full verdict breakdown were not retrievable at filing time.

The figure sits inside a run of large obstetrics verdicts this fall: $84 million against Fairview Health Services in Hennepin County, Minnesota (reported October 9); roughly $14.2 million in Oakland County, Michigan over a missed stroke diagnosis (October 12); and a Bakersfield, California OB-GYN wrongful-death verdict (October 21) where MICRA caps will limit the collectible non-economic award regardless of the jury number.

Separately, the Daily Journal reported a $21.9 million verdict on November 9 in a fatal garbage-truck case, but the caption, venue specifics and defendant identity remain behind a paywall. Trucking-liability counsel should flag this one for follow-up once the opinion or docket becomes public.

Counsel tracking comparable damages should treat the Boyd figure as provisional until post-trial motions and the full verdict form surface.

Fee Economics: Chong Ruling Still Shaping Termination Disputes

Chong v. Mardirossian Akaragian LLP, No. B341157 (2d Dist., Div. 5, January 8, 2026, partially published), remains the operative California anchor on fees after a client fires counsel. The court affirmed summary judgment awarding the firm its full 45 percent contingency fee plus prejudgment interest, built on a $6,015,000 policy-limits settlement reached in May 2022.

A 2024 trial-court tentative ruling had put the claimed fee and costs at $2,761,380.29, a trial-level number that may not match the final judgment affirmed on appeal. The court's logic turned on ratification: once a client accepts the benefit of counsel's work under a valid contract, quantum meruit does not automatically displace the contract rate on termination.

For firm operators, the practical read is about successor-counsel risk. Any referral or co-counsel agreement drafted without clear termination language is exposed to the same fight Mardirossian Akaragian won, and losing it would have meant a quantum meruit recalculation on a seven-figure settlement.

Firms taking referred cases from terminated counsel should confirm the predecessor's fee agreement and ratification history before signing the new retainer.

Billed-vs-Paid Still the Floor: Pebley, Howell, and a Quiet Appellate Week

No new dated appellate, MDL or Daubert ruling with a confirmed caption and dollar figure surfaced for November 14 through 20. That makes this a good week to restate the California damages floor rather than chase a headline that is not there.

Pebley v. Santa Clara Organics (2018) still governs lien-based treatment: a plaintiff who elects to treat on a lien, even if insured, is treated as uninsured for purposes of admitting full billed amounts. The reviewing court modified that judgment by only $1,063, and the Supreme Court's disposition of the related petition for review was not confirmed in this week's research.

Howell v. Hamilton Meats (2011) caps an insured plaintiff's past medical damages at amounts paid or owed. Qaadir v. Figueroa (2021) followed Pebley and declined to follow Ochoa v. Dorado, a split Horvitz & Levy has flagged for future resolution.

Hair relaxer MDL 3060 had summary judgment and non-general-causation Daubert motions due November 16, a filing deadline rather than a ruling. Watch for orders in the next cycle.

Nothing this week moves the billed-versus-paid line, so lien valuation strategy should still default to Pebley and Howell until a new opinion lands.

Recall Exposure: BMW and Honda/Acura Lead a 1.4 Million-Vehicle Week

NHTSA campaign 26V733000 covers 720,796 BMW vehicles, model years 2012 through 2018 across the 3, 4 and 5 Series, Z4, X1, X3, X4 and the X5 xDrive40e. An improperly sealed water-pump electrical connector allows water intrusion that can short-circuit and raise fire risk.

Campaign 26V721000 covers 635,808 Honda and Acura vehicles: the 2021 to 2025 TLX, 2022 to 2024 MDX, and 2023 to 2025 Pilot. A software defect can drop the power-steering system into failsafe mode, producing sudden loss of steering assist.

Smaller campaigns worth docketing: Lincoln Navigator (26V691000, 36,994 units, unintended passenger-seat movement in chauffeur mode), Ford Maverick Hybrid (26V724000, 8,650 units, a loose 12-volt battery cable terminal), and the Ford Police Interceptor Utility (26V726, roughly 33,578 units per a secondary source, a map-light defect).

Auto and products counsel should run client VIN lists against all five campaigns before relying on unrelated causation theories for related mechanical failures.

Operations Desk: Lien Tracking Gets a New Line Item

California's SB 623 takes effect for rideshare crashes arising on or after January 1, 2027, and requires disclosure when a medical lien has been sold or financed. Recovery on a sold lien is then capped at whatever price the buyer paid for it, not the face value billed.

Medical providers who sell or factor receivables on rideshare claims should expect disclosure demands from defense counsel starting with 2027 dates of loss, and should build that disclosure into intake paperwork now rather than at deposition.

Firms need an intake field that flags lien chain of custody before a referral or lien-based treatment plan is finalized, because the recoverable value now depends on the sale price, not the original bill. New York's Litigation Funding Act, effective June 17, 2026, adds a parallel layer nationally: a charge cap, a 10-business-day cancellation window, and a priority scheme that puts lawyer, Medicare and statutory liens ahead of the funder.

On the intake side, CallRail's 2026 survey still ranks phone as the preferred first-contact channel even as short-form video and AI tools climb the marketing-trend list, and Lawmatics notes most inquiries get shopped to several firms simultaneously.

Providers and firms working rideshare or financed-lien files should treat lien-sale disclosure as a 2027 compliance item, not a future problem.

What to Watch Before the Next Wrap

The $21.9 million garbage-truck verdict still lacks a public caption, defendant name or venue confirmation beyond the Daily Journal's November 9 report. That detail matters for any trucking-liability comparison set being built for mediation.

Hair relaxer MDL 3060's November 16 Daubert and summary judgment deadline should start producing orders in the coming weeks, which will matter for general-causation strategy across pending state-court filings tied to the same product class.

SB 623 guidance ahead of its January 1, 2027 effective date has not yet been published by the state bar or DOI, leaving firms to build disclosure workflows against bill text alone for now.

720,796 is the vehicle count on the BMW recall alone this week, more than double the Honda and Acura campaign, and neither manufacturer has disclosed a confirmed fire or crash count tied to the defect.

Who LawyersTrend is for

Three ways in

Selling to the PI bar? See sponsor and advertiser options.